Chapter 1: The Incident Unfolds

On December 6, 2010, what began as a simple goodnight kiss spiraled into a horrific event. When William Lueders contacted emergency services around 11 p.m., the operator struggled to comprehend his slurred words. It wasn't until the police arrived that the shocking reality came to light. The evening had begun like any other, but in the days leading up to this incident, Karen Lueders had exhibited unusual behavior.

At 57, Karen, who was a dedicated Christian minister, had become increasingly vocal about her spirituality, her sentiments growing more frantic and insistent. While such discussions were typical for the couple, who operated a music ministry together, William, now 79, sensed that something was amiss. He observed that Karen had been acting strangely that night, yet he dismissed it and proceeded with their usual routine.

As the clock struck 11:15 p.m., Karen was in the bathroom, seated on the toilet. William entered to give her a loving French kiss, but the ensuing events would haunt him for years.