Understanding Cultural Variations in Music Perception
Written on
Chapter 1: Do Cultures Experience Music Differently?
How do we experience music in our bodies? For instance, when listening to the song “Shallow” from "A Star is Born," do you feel a pang of sorrow, a shiver, or perhaps something entirely different? Music isn’t merely a series of sound waves hitting our eardrums; it resonates within us physically.
But this notion varies widely among cultures. For example, listeners in China might feel the emotional weight of “Shallow” more in their stomachs, while those in America may experience it predominantly in their chests. This raises an important question: Are our bodily reactions to music universal, or do they differ across cultures?
Global Resonance: A Study of Bodily Reactions to Music
To investigate this, researchers from Finnish and Chinese universities collaborated to explore whether music elicits similar physical sensations and emotions worldwide. Do people from different parts of the globe react similarly to the same melodies? To answer this, the study recruited 1,938 participants from Europe, North America, and East Asia, exposing them to a variety of musical genres, including happy, sad, and other emotional categories. This included both familiar and unfamiliar tunes.
Participants were tasked with coloring human silhouettes to indicate where they felt sensations like warmth, tension, or relaxation while listening. This exercise, performed using the emBODY tool, mapped their bodily reactions akin to a musical version of Twister.
Did they respond similarly, or did cultural differences emerge?
Surprisingly, the results showed that music affects individuals similarly across cultures. Upbeat and danceable songs prompted sensations in the arms, legs, and heads—a full-body experience. Examples of cheerful tunes included Pharrell Williams’ “Happy” and Katrina and The Waves’ “Walking on Sunshine.” Dance tracks like Mark Ronson’s “Uptown Funk” and Daft Punk’s “Get Lucky” elicited similar responses.
In contrast, slower ballads tended to evoke feelings concentrated in the chest and head, as seen with Adele’s “Someone Like You” and Ed Sheeran’s “Perfect.” On the other hand, intense or aggressive compositions triggered strong sensations in the head, with tracks like the “Jaws” theme and Metallica’s “Enter Sandman” demonstrating this effect.
However, the study did not provide explicit correlation figures for each emotional response.
The study revealed that responses among Western and East Asian participants ranged from 0.80 to 0.91, indicating that music is similarly perceived across different cultures. This consistency in emotional responses highlights the profound impact music has on us universally.
Implications and Insights
What does this mean for us? Firstly, it suggests that we can map emotional qualities in music to distinct bodily sensations, revealing a universal pattern of response that transcends cultural boundaries. Secondly, this knowledge can be harnessed for therapeutic purposes, with music therapists potentially using specific songs to help individuals manage their emotions or stress, given the universal nature of these effects.
Lastly, what we often think of as a universal language—music—may have deeper biological roots than previously understood. Regardless of cultural background, it seems we are inherently wired to respond to music in similar ways, reflecting a common emotional thread among all humans.
Music can serve as a powerful unifying force, fostering connections among individuals regardless of their differences.
Final Thoughts
Music continually surprises us. This study shows that individuals from diverse cultures experience the emotional impact of music in remarkably similar ways, evidenced by their physical reactions. While we once viewed music as merely a mode of communication, we now recognize its capacity to evoke specific bodily sensations tied to emotions.
Music resonates with us on a biological level, akin to a mathematical structure ingrained in our lives. Ultimately, it stands as a profound unifier of human emotions.
To delve deeper into the world of sound and its effects, consider joining my newsletter, where over 250 subscribers explore the intersections of music, psychology, and technology.
History and Science Prove Music Can Turn Foes into Friends
Here’s to more orchestras and fewer armies!
3 Unusual Approaches to Tackle Climate Change… With Sound
What happens when the climate crisis hits your ears?
This video titled "Do musicians hear music differently? | Science of Sound" explores how musicians perceive music uniquely, highlighting their distinct emotional responses.
In this TEDx talk, "How culture affects our taste in music," Sophia Gisonda discusses the diverse influences of culture on our musical preferences and experiences.