Exploring Real Estate and Stocks: A Rational Perspective
Written on
Chapter 1: The Investment Landscape
In the realm of investing, discussions often center around the stock market. However, when it comes to risk-adjusted returns, real estate takes the lead.
A study conducted in 2017 by researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco titled "The Rate of Return on Everything, 1870–2015," revealed that from 1870 to 2015, the global stock market yielded real returns of 6.89% annually, while global real estate outperformed with returns of 7.05%. Not only did real estate deliver superior returns, but it also did so with notably lower volatility.
While global real estate presents a more stable investment with better returns, the situation is nuanced. Let's delve into the complexities and how real estate can fit into your investment strategy.
Section 1.1: Homeownership vs. Real Estate Investment
Understanding what investing in real estate means to you is crucial. There are two primary avenues for real estate investment:
- Owning a home
- Acquiring rental properties
Homeownership as an Investment
It’s important to highlight that the 7.05% annual return is not applicable to owner-occupied homes. Homeowners typically benefit from two main income streams in real estate:
- Rental income
- Appreciation of property value
However, when you reside in your home, you forgo rental income, significantly diminishing that 7.05% return. Thus, living in your home is generally not a superior investment compared to stocks.
Here are additional factors that make homeownership less appealing than investing in stocks via index funds:
- Idiosyncratic Risk: This term refers to risks specific to an individual asset rather than the market as a whole. Homeownership embodies idiosyncratic risk in its purest form. When you purchase a home, you’re investing in a single unit of a broad asset class, real estate, which is influenced by numerous localized factors.
- Location Matters: The adage “location, location, location” rings true in real estate. Each market is distinct, and various elements can influence property values significantly.
Section 1.2: The Realities of Homeownership
Before the financial crisis of 2008-2009, many believed that home prices in the U.S. would perpetually rise. However, the downturn challenged that assumption, yet homes are still deemed safe investments.
According to Federal Reserve research, the standard deviation of global real estate returns is about half that of global stocks, indicating less price volatility. Nevertheless, this does not equate to safety. While housing is less volatile than a fully equity-based portfolio, it carries its own risks.
A 2017 study, "The Home as a Risky Asset" by David Blanchett, suggested that the risk associated with homeownership is comparable to a balanced portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds. Moreover, when considering maintenance costs, taxes, and transaction fees, the returns for homeowners often lag behind inflation, particularly for those who move frequently.
The Advantages of Homeownership
Despite its risks, owning a home can be advantageous. A mortgage creates a form of enforced savings, as part of your payment contributes to equity. Additionally, many countries offer tax benefits to homeowners. In the U.S., mortgage interest can be deducted from taxable income, while Canadians are exempt from capital gains taxes on their primary residence.
One subtle yet significant benefit is that homeownership can serve as a form of rent control. With a fixed-rate mortgage, your housing expenses remain relatively stable, shielding you from potential rent hikes. As your income grows, your housing costs will diminish as a percentage of your earnings, enabling more investment in index funds.
Once the mortgage is settled, your housing expenses typically reduce to property taxes and maintenance, akin to receiving tax-free income.
Chapter 2: Rental Properties as a Wealth-Building Tool
Investing in rental properties diverges greatly from purchasing a home for personal use. Historically, rental properties have provided an annual return of 7.05%. However, this does not imply that you should liquidate your index funds to invest in rentals.
Self-managing rental properties transforms your investment into a business. Your success hinges on your ability to find lucrative deals, secure tenants, and manage the property effectively. While rental properties can be excellent wealth generators, poor decisions can lead to significant financial loss.
In contrast, investing in a diversified index fund requires minimal effort; you invest and let it grow passively. Although real estate may seem more exciting and glamorous, the boring yet sensible approach of index investing is often more effective.
It's crucial to note that the 7.05% return on real estate does not factor in property taxes, which typically account for around 1% of a property's value. When including these taxes, the net return drops to approximately 6.05%, which is lower than stocks.
Additionally, investing in real estate globally can be challenging due to high transaction costs and the size of individual properties. Unlike real estate, which can be cumbersome to diversify, investing in a global index fund is straightforward and efficient.
Finally, liquidity poses a significant drawback in real estate. If you own a rental property valued at $500,000, you can't sell a portion of it easily. The process of selling an entire property is time-consuming and costly. In contrast, selling parts of your index fund investments can be done almost instantaneously at minimal cost.
In conclusion, while real estate—especially homeownership—offers many non-financial benefits, it also presents various challenges. For a deeper discussion on these non-financial aspects, consider exploring further resources.
This article is derived from a chapter in my book, The Rational Investor.
Note: This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial or legal advice. Always consult a financial professional before making significant financial decisions.