# The Quest to Unravel the Mysteries of Merging Black Holes
Written on
Chapter 1: The Intriguing Dance of Black Holes
Do black holes merge? This question is at the heart of recent astronomical discoveries regarding two supermassive black holes on a collision path. As these colossal entities draw closer to one another, they promise to shed light on the elusive 'background hum' of gravitational waves, which has long puzzled scientists.
Researchers have identified a distant pair of black holes, each boasting a mass equivalent to 800 million suns, that are on a trajectory toward collision. As they approach their fateful encounter, these supermassive black holes will generate ripples in the fabric of space-time, contributing to the gravitational wave background produced by other similar black holes.
Even before the impending collision, the gravitational waves emitted by this pair are expected to far exceed those previously recorded from the mergers of smaller black holes and neutron stars. Chiara Mingarelli, an associate research scientist at the Flatiron Institute’s Center for Computational Astrophysics, who is also a co-discoverer of their trajectories, stated: “Supermassive black hole binaries produce the loudest gravitational waves in the universe.” In fact, the gravitational waves from these supermassive black holes are anticipated to be a million times more powerful than those detected by LIGO.
This remarkable discovery, led by Andy Goulding, an associate research scholar at Princeton University, was detailed in a recent study published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
A galaxy located approximately 2.5 billion light-years from Earth harbors this intriguing duo of supermassive black holes. Their positions are illuminated by the warm gas and brilliant stars enveloping them. This finding enhances astronomers' ability to estimate when they might first detect the gravitational wave background produced by supermassive black holes. The black holes exist in a universe that is 2.5 billion years younger than ours, which correlates to the time frame in which they are expected to start generating significant gravitational waves.
Currently, these black holes are already emitting gravitational waves, yet, despite traveling at light speed, these waves will take billions of years to reach us. Understanding this discovery will assist scientists in estimating how many nearby supermassive black holes are currently emitting detectable gravitational waves.
Section 1.1: Unraveling the Final Parse Problem
Detecting the gravitational wave background will address some of astronomy's most pressing questions, such as the frequency of galactic mergers and whether pairs of supermassive black holes ultimately merge or remain in orbit around one another. Co-author Jenny Greene, a professor of astrophysical sciences at Princeton, emphasized the significance of this inquiry: “It’s a major embarrassment for astronomy that we don’t know if supermassive black holes merge. For everyone in black hole physics, observationally this is a long-standing puzzle that we need to solve.”
It is widely believed that nearly all galaxies, including our own Milky Way, contain at least one supermassive black hole at their centers. When galaxies merge, their supermassive black holes begin to orbit one another. Over time, this orbit tightens as gas and stars pass between them, draining angular momentum and energy from the system. However, when the black holes draw close enough, this angular momentum drain essentially halts.
Theoretical studies suggest that black holes may become "stuck" about 1 parsec (approximately 3.2 light-years) apart, leading to what is known as the final parse problem. In this case, only rare groupings of three or more supermassive black holes are expected to result in actual mergers.
Because astronomers cannot simply look for these stalled pairs—since they are too close to distinguish as separate entities—detecting them becomes a challenge. Strong gravitational waves only emerge once the final parse hurdle is overcome.
If this problem does not persist, astronomers anticipate a universe filled with numerous gravitational waves from supermassive black hole pairs. Goulding elaborates on this noise, describing it as a “gravitational wave background,” akin to a chaotic chorus of crickets on a summer night. “You can’t discern one cricket from another, but the volume of the noise helps you estimate how many crickets are out there.”
The final collision of two supermassive black holes should produce a thunderous chirp that overshadows the surrounding background noise. Unfortunately, this event is both brief and exceedingly rare, leading scientists to expect that detecting such an occurrence will not happen soon.
The first video, "Scientists Just Detected Two Supermassive Black Holes on a Collision Course," discusses the recent findings regarding these black holes and their implications for gravitational wave research.
Section 1.2: Pulsars: The Cosmic Metronomes
Gravitational waves generated by pairs of supermassive black holes exist outside the frequencies that current experiments like LIGO and Virgo can observe. Instead, researchers depend on arrays of pulsars—rapidly spinning stars that emit radio waves in a consistent rhythm—as their timing reference. When a gravitational wave passes by, it can stretch or compress the space between Earth and the pulsar, causing slight disruptions in this rhythm.
Detecting the gravitational wave background using pulsar timing arrays requires immense patience and continuous monitoring. A single pulsar's rhythm might only be disturbed by a few hundred nanoseconds over a decade. The louder the background noise, the greater the timing disruption, leading to the earlier detection of these waves.
Although supermassive black holes cannot be directly viewed with optical telescopes, they are surrounded by luminous clusters of stars and warm gas attracted by their immense gravitational force. This allowed the research team to identify them using the Hubble Space Telescope.
Goulding noted that the host galaxy was “basically the most luminous galaxy in the universe” at the time of observation. Notably, the galaxy's core was emitting two unusually large, collimated gas plumes. Targeting the Hubble Space Telescope at this galaxy led to the discovery of two massive black holes instead of just one.
Following their observation, the team collaborated with gravitational wave physicists Mingarelli and Princeton graduate student Kris Pardo to interpret their findings in the context of the gravitational wave background. This discovery serves as a foundation for estimating how many supermassive black hole pairs could be within detection range of Earth.
The second video, "When Black Holes Collide," explores the science behind black hole mergers and the gravitational waves they produce.
Counting Supermassive Black Hole Pairs
Pardo and Mingarelli project that, under optimistic conditions, there are approximately 112 nearby supermassive black holes actively emitting gravitational waves. This suggests that the first detection of the gravitational wave background from supermassive black holes could occur within the next five years. If such a detection does not materialize, it may indicate that the final parse problem is indeed insurmountable.
The research team is currently investigating other galaxies similar to the one housing the newly discovered supermassive black hole pair, hoping that additional findings will refine their predictions.